Opinion - 28/November/2019

If not insurable, is it bankable?

Jonas Dalsgaard, Global Sales & Business Development Manager at Codan, asks how the insurance market should react to insuring the increasing number of big wind farms in areas of the world that frequently experience natural disasters

Collaboration between project developers, brokers and insurers is vital for the continued insurability of large-scale offshore wind farms in areas prone to natural catastrophes

 

Certain parts of Asia are prone to natural disasters like typhoons and earthquakes. These phenomena mean the region is not a great match with the massive renewables energy infrastructure investments that are planned and already underway. Japan, South Korea, China and Taiwan are all vulnerable as are many parts of the US, which has several large offshore wind farms in the pipeline.

Expertise in offshore wind insurance sits in the heads of a few experienced insurers and brokers mainly from Europe. None of them have any real experience of natural catastrophes in these regions since no-one has yet had to deal with the impacts of a big typhoon or earthquake hitting an offshore wind farm.

At a technology level, manufacturers are developing typhoon resistant turbines, but they have yet to be put to the test in real-life conditions. For insurers, this means risk can only be assessed based on modelling, rather than actual experience. Instead, insurers are basing their assumptions and analysis on experience from other industries that are as close to offshore wind as possible. Such uncertainties will drive an increase in premiums as insurers will need to add in a buffer to accommodate the considerable unknowns.

Another, and more serious, matter for project developers is potentially being left without any insurance capacity following an accumulation of risk.

 

 

The general view within the energy insurance industry is that wind energy assets will be less susceptible to large losses than oil and gas on the basis that the value concentration is much less and spread across a bigger area. For an individual wind farm owner, however, the risk remains that the available insurance capacity will not be enough to de-risk a project and satisfy lenders.

Until now, the insurance market has been able to offer individual offshore wind farms in Asia with full cover. As greater numbers of wind farms are built and start operating in the region, however, there will be an increased concentration of values, especially in areas like Taiwan, where all planned wind farms are in the Taiwan Strait.

There are good reasons for stacking up offshore wind farms in that relatively small geographical area as typhoons are less severe there than in other parts of the country. But, at the same time, it means insurers will have to control how much capacity they can deploy in the area. In insurance terms, this is referred to as accumulation of risk. It basically means the values onsite exceed what the insurance industry can pay in the event of a major natural catastrophe loss where a strong typhoon goes through an area where multiple wind farms have been deployed.

Such a shortage of capacity can prove a real challenge to project developers and owners who so far have sought to pass the entire risk of natural disasters onto the insurance market. The new reality will be that clients will have to accept significant limitations in the protection they buy and this may affect the appetite of investors for offshore wind assets in areas prone to these risks.

Ultimately the question arises: if a project is not insurable, is it bankable? The likelihood is that the offshore market will continue to grow and will not be forced to slow down because of issues related to insurance.

Developers and project owners in vulnerable areas must, however, prepare themselves for a different risk appetite from insurers and develop strategies in which they are willing to accept more risk on their own balance sheet. At the same time, insurers must invest more resources in understanding and quantifying onsite exposure and work proactively to solve the problem. Insurance brokers are also looking at the issue and starting to develop reinsurance protection that insurers could tap into if and when necessary.

Collaboration between project developers, brokers and insurers is pivotal for success and the continued insurability of large-scale offshore wind farms in areas prone to natural catastrophes.

 


The views expressed in this opinion are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the position of FORESIGHT Climate & Energy

Do you have a thoughtful response to the opinion expressed here? Do you have an opinion regarding an aspect of the global energy transition you would like to share with other FORESIGHT readers? If so, please send a short pitch of 200 words and a sentence explaining why you are the right person to deliver this opinion to opinion@foresightdk.com.

Share


Related articles

Offshore wind pushes boundaries in North Sea

Europe’s offshore wind revolution requires a more integrated approach

Read more

New permit rules for nearshore Danish wind projects

The new rules may cause “more work and more risk” for developers

Read more

Time to shift our focus

While the growth of renewables is accelerating, energy-related greenhouse gas emissions keep increasing. Getting serious about climate change mitigation requires a significant shift of focus, says Morten Dyrholm, Group Senior Vice President at Vestas Wind Systems. If each part of the energy sector continues working in isolation, we will miss opportunities to collaborate on solutions.

Read more

Diverse solutions

The offshore wind market has made massive progress as prices fall, farms get larger and technologies smarter and more efficient. All this is thanks to competent, skilled and creative people. As the demand for clean electricity grows, diverse workforces in terms of gender, background, discipline and culture will be a significant asset, says Jovana Filipovic, Senior Offshore Analyst at LM Wind Power

Read more

The offshore renewables sector is beginning to use robots in similar ways to the offshore oil and gas industries in an effort to cut costs

Offshore renewables reach for robotics

Robots have long been used by the offshore oil and gas sector to reduce the costs of installing facilities and operations and maintenance. The offshore renewables sector is starting to benefit from the technology, which could help it make significant cost savings if certain technical hurdles can be overcome

Read more

The energy transition must be gender-equitable

As the Global Wind Energy Council (GWEC) and the Global Women’s Network for the Energy Transition bring women working in the wind industry in emerging markets to Europe to encourage action on the Sustainable Development Goals, GWEC’s Joyce Lee explains why the energy transition will only be successful if women are able to fully participate

Read more

Big business sees route to zero carbon electricity

Online platforms can deliver transparency around PPAs, bring down transaction costs and enable new entrants in the market

Read more

Putting principles before profit?

Expectations are high that the Principles for Sustainable Banking can push banks to change their balance sheets and businesses in line with climate action and other big societal issues

Read more

Processing...
Thank you! Your subscription has been confirmed. You'll hear from us soon.
SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER
Sign up to the FORESIGHT Climate & Energy Newsletter. Get free opinion pieces and photo essays. You will also be the first to know when new expert articles are published.
ErrorHere